Living with a disability can make working challenging, particularly when your employer refuses to provide the accommodations you need to perform your job. If your medical condition prevents you from working and your employer is unwilling or unable to accommodate your limitations, you may be wondering how you will pay your bills and support yourself.
One question many employees ask is: Can I qualify for short-term or long-term disability benefits if I cannot work because my employer is not accommodating my disability?
The answer is yes, potentially. You may qualify for short-term disability (STD) or long-term disability (LTD) benefits if your medical condition prevents you from performing your job and you meet the eligibility requirements of your disability insurance policy. However, qualifying for disability benefits involves different legal standards than establishing that your employer violated your rights under the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA).
Understanding the difference between these protections can help you determine your legal options and protect your financial future. The experienced employment discrimination and disability law attorneys at Hawks Quindel can help you navigate your options.
Can I Receive Disability Benefits If My Employer Refuses to Accommodate My Disability?
You may qualify for short-term or long-term disability benefits even if your inability to work is related to your employer’s failure to accommodate your disability.
Disability insurance is an employment benefit offered by many employers that generally provides income replacement when a medical condition prevents you from working, subject to the terms and conditions of your policy. It is important to note that not all employers offer disability insurance benefits, and the terms and conditions of a particular employer’s policy may differ considerably from another employer’s policy.
To illustrate when an employer’s failure to accommodate an employee might permit a claim for disability insurance benefits, consider an employee who has a chronic medical condition that causes significant fatigue and difficulty concentrating. The employee asks the employer for a modified work schedule, additional breaks, or permission to work remotely. The employer refuses these requests.
As a result, the employee’s symptoms worsen, and the employee can no longer maintain a regular work schedule.
The employer offers its employees STD and LTD benefits. To qualify under this particular employer’s plan, the employee must be unable to perform the duties of their own occupation.
In this situation, the employee may have two separate legal issues:
- A potential employment discrimination claim: The employer may have violated the ADA by failing to provide a reasonable accommodation.
- A potential disability insurance claim: The employee may qualify for short-term or long-term disability benefits if the medical condition renders them unable to perform the duties of their own occupation.
Importantly, an employer’s failure to accommodate your disability does not automatically establish eligibility for disability insurance benefits. Likewise, you do not necessarily have to prove that your employer violated the ADA to qualify for benefits.
Each issue must be evaluated independently.
Does My Employer Have to Accommodate My Disability Before I Can Apply for Disability Benefits?
No. Generally, you do not have to exhaust your employer’s reasonable accommodation obligations before applying for disability benefits.
The Americans with Disabilities Act requires covered employers to provide reasonable accommodations to qualified employees with disabilities unless doing so would create an undue hardship.
Depending on the circumstances, reasonable accommodations may include:
- Modified work schedules.
- Additional breaks.
- Remote or hybrid work arrangements.
- Modified equipment or workspaces.
- Changes to certain workplace policies.
- Temporary or additional medical leave.
- Reassignment to an available vacant position.
An employer generally cannot simply refuse to consider an accommodation request because it is inconvenient or because the employee’s disability requires changes to normal workplace procedures. However, employers are not required to provide accommodations in all circumstances, particularly when an accommodation would impose an undue hardship.
If your employer refuses to provide an effective reasonable accommodation, you may have grounds to pursue an employment discrimination claim.
It is important to understand that an employer’s obligation to accommodate you and an insurance company’s obligation to pay disability benefits are separate legal questions. The employment discrimination attorneys at Hawks Quindel can help you understand whether your employer’s refusal to accommodate your conditions constitutes a violation of disability discrimination laws.
Can I Qualify for Disability Benefits If I Am Physically Able to Work but My Employer Will Not Accommodate Me?
This is an important distinction.
Short-term and long-term disability insurance policies generally evaluate whether your medical condition prevents you from performing the occupational duties identified in your policy.
If you can perform your job with reasonable accommodations but your employer refuses to provide them, you may have a stronger employment discrimination claim than a disability insurance claim.
For example, imagine an employee with a back condition who cannot safely lift heavy objects but can perform other job responsibilities. The employee requests assistance with lifting or a modification of certain physical duties.
If the employer refuses, the employee may be unable to continue working in that particular position.
However, the insurance company may argue that the employee is not disabled under the policy because the medical condition does not prevent the employee from performing the occupation as defined by the policy, because the employee might be able to perform the occupation with accommodations.
The outcome depends on the policy language, the employee’s actual medical restrictions, and the nature of the job.
On the other hand, if your medical condition prevents you from performing the essential duties of your occupation, even with reasonable accommodations, you may have a stronger basis for qualifying for disability benefits.
The experienced disability attorneys at Hawks Quindel can help evaluate whether your medical limitations satisfy the applicable insurance policy’s definition of disability.
Can I Receive Disability Benefits and Pursue an ADA Claim Against My Employer?
Potentially, yes.
You may have the right to pursue disability insurance benefits while also asserting that your employer violated the ADA.
These claims serve different purposes:
Disability insurance benefits: These benefits are intended to replace a portion of your income when you cannot work because of a qualifying medical condition.
ADA employment protections: These protections prohibit covered employers from discriminating against qualified employees because of disabilities and require reasonable accommodations when legally appropriate.
These protections can overlap, but they are not interchangeable. Receiving disability benefits does not automatically establish an ADA violation, and pursuing an ADA claim does not automatically establish eligibility for disability insurance. In some circumstances, disability discrimination claims and disability insurance benefits claims can be mutually exclusive.
Should I Contact an Attorney If I Cannot Work Because My Employer Will Not Accommodate My Disability?
Being unable to work because of a disability is stressful enough without having to worry about an employer refusing to accommodate your medical needs or an insurance company denying your disability benefits.
Fortunately, you may have legal options.
You do not have to navigate these issues alone. The experienced employment discrimination and disability benefits attorneys at Hawks Quindel can review your circumstances, explain your rights, and help determine the best way to pursue the benefits and protections available to you.
Contact Hawks Quindel today to discuss your situation and learn how we may be able to help
The post I Can’t Work Because My Employer Is Refusing to Accommodate My Disability. Can I Qualify for Short-Term or Long-Term Disability Benefits? appeared first on Hawks Quindel, S.C..
