In an ideal world, the tenant would return their keys, remove all personal property (including trash), and leave the rental unit spotless. Then it would be clear that the tenant has surrendered the rental unit and, as there wouldn’t be any personal property remaining, there would be nothing to debate its abandonment. Unfortunately, that rarely happens.

In this situation, there are generally two main issues: (1) Has the tenant surrendered the rental unit (i.e. vacated and has no need to come back to clean, pick up personal property, or for any other reason); and (2) Has the tenant abandoned any remaining personal property.  In this post we will discuss the first issue: Has the tenant surrendered the rental unit?

Surrender of the Rental Unit:

The gold standard to confirm that a tenant has surrendered a rental unit is for the tenant to return the keys to the rental unit to the landlord. If the tenant has returned the keys to the landlord, he or she can’t get back into the unit and thus they are not planning to come back and clean or remove more personal property.

So, if it looks like a tenant may have left but not returned the keys, you should try and contact the tenant and get him or her to return the keys.

If that isn’t an option, the next best scenario would be for the tenant to sign a statement that he or she has surrendered the rental unit.

If that isn’t an option, the next best scenario is to talk with the tenant and have him or her tell you that he or she has surrendered the rental unit and then follow that conversation up with a letter to the tenant confirming the date and time you spoke with him/her and that he or she told you they had surrendered the rental unit.

If the tenant does not respond to any of your attempts to contact him or her, then you have to make a decision. Should you:

  1. Play it safe and serve a notice for failure to pay rent, file an eviction, and have the Sheriff execute the writ.  This is the safest way to proceed, but also the most time-consuming and costly; or
  2. Assume that the tenant has surrendered the rental unit and change the locks.

I have had to defend landlords who have chosen Option #2 and been sued by the tenant who claims the landlord engaged in an illegal self-help eviction by changing the locks without going through the judicial eviction process.  So such lawsuits do happen and it often takes quite a bit of money to resolve such lawsuits depending on the amount and quality of the personal property that was disposed of by the landlord.

Most of my clients are more risk adverse and always elect to follow option #1. But , I do have other client that are willing to take the risk and go for option #2.

If the landlord wants to pursue option #2, then I recommend that the landlord document the file with any and all attempts made to determine or confirm that the tenant has surrendered the rental unit. Examples would include:

  • Memos to the file noting all the attempts the landlord made to contact the tenant to confirm he or she has vacated;
  • Memo to file of all telephone calls to the tenant’s emergency contact or other known family members who confirmed that tenant has vacated;
  • Interview neighbors and document the last time they saw the tenant (sometimes the next door neighbor will tell you that they saw the tenant pull up in a moving van the day before and load it up and then the tenant waived good-bye to them);
  • You could run a CCAP search on the tenant to see if the tenant has been arrested and is in jail (in which case you will definitely need to proceed with the eviction process) or got a recent speeding ticket and gave a new address;
  • Take pictures of the rental unit showing what, if any, personal property the tenant left behind (ideally it will be trash or items that aren’t necessary for day-to-day living like toiletries, mail with old dates and addresses on it, expired food, etc.).

The goal is to document the file so that if you opt to change the locks, and the tenant later sues you for performing an illegal eviction, you would be able to prove to a court that you did investigate and try to determine if the tenant had surrendered the rental unit and; further, that based on all the information you obtained, a reasonable person would have determined that the tenant had surrendered the renal unit as well.

Unfortunately, there is not a bright line test to determine whether or not a landlord is “safe” in changing the locks on the rental unit or if the landlord should instead go through with the eviction process. That is why the decision often hinges on the landlord’s aversion to risk.

Stay tuned for my next blog post – I Think That My Tenant Has Vacated the Rental Unit, What Do I Do Now? PART 2: Abandonment of Personal Property