Constitutional

Oct. 27, 2026 — A Milwaukee County sheriff’s deputy whose distracted driving resulted in a fatal accident has qualified immunity, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit decided in Estate of Ceaser Stinson v. Joel Streicher, No. 22-3043 (Oct. 14, 2026). It’s the first case to decide whether inattentive driving could violate substantive due process under County of Sacramento v. Lewis, 523 U.S. 833 (1998). “Officer Streicher’s distractedness — regardless of the source — was negligent,…
Continue Reading Seventh Circuit: Deputy Involved in Fatal Crash Gets Qualified Immunity

Wisconsin’s Legislature asks voters to pass a constitutional amendment that in essence refutes the legitimacy of the 1964 Civil Rights Act.

The proposed amendment, question 3 on the Nov. 3 ballot, follows a national movement that seeks to reframe civil rights laws as discriminatory against white Americans. It passed through the Legislature along party lines.

A lead sponsor, Rep. Dave Murphy (R-Hortonville), says the amendment would prohibit governmental entities from “discriminating against or granting preferential treatment to

…
Continue Reading Opinion: Anti-equity amendment is for a post-racial state we haven't built yet

Oct. 14, 2026 — A case against a 10-year-old charged with first-degree murder in the shooting death of his mother has raised constitutional issues of national importance.A primary question is whether the attributes of youth, as described by the U.S. Supreme Court, apply in determining whether the defendant should be tried as an adult.A nationally known public interest lawyer, Bryan Stevenson, is representing the defendant in State v. Mann-Tate. Oral arguments were Sept. 8.Seven justices will decide whether the…
Continue Reading Reverse Waiver: Supreme Court Reviews Jurisdiction for 10-Year-Old in Murder Case

Wisconsin voters will encounter three constitutional amendment referendum questions on the Nov. 3 ballot. In a series of posts, Wisconsin Justice Initiative will help you understand constitutional amendment referendum questions generally, and the Nov. 3 election questions specifically. This is part five in the series. Find prior posts here.

By Alexandria Staubach and Margo Kirchner

Ballot question 3 is the most destructive proposed constitutional amendment voters will face on Nov. 3; it’s a regressive ploy.

The proposed amendment

…
Continue Reading November ballot question 3: Prohibiting targeted government benefits for minority individuals and women

Wisconsin voters will encounter three constitutional amendment referendum questions on the Nov. 3 ballot. In a series of posts, Wisconsin Justice Initiative will help you understand constitutional amendment referendum questions generally, and the Nov. 3 election questions specifically. This is part four in the series. Find parts one, two, and three here, here, and here. ​

Wisconsin legislators are asking voters to approve a constitutional amendment purportedly about religious liberty, but which many religiously leaders

…
Continue Reading November ballot question 2: Banning closure of places of worship during an emergency

The Eleventh Circuit recently rejected a challenge to the constitutionality of the False Claims Act’s (“FCA”) qui tam provisions, holding that whistleblowers who bring FCA actions are not “Officers of the United States” subject to the Constitution’s Appointments Clause. United States ex rel. Zafirov v. Florida Medical Associates, No. 24-13581, 2026 WL 2581886 (11th Cir. Sept. 1, 2026).
Background
The relator brought an FCA action alleging Medicare fraud. The defendants moved to dismiss, arguing that the FCA’s qui tam…
Continue Reading Eleventh Circuit Rejects Constitutional Challenge to the False Claims Act’s Qui Tam Provision

 
Wisconsin Justice Initiative is providing an in-depth look at the constitutional amendments Wisconsin voters will see on their Nov. 3 ballots. This is part two in a series, providing the full text of each ballot question and each proposed amendment as well as the effect the amendment has on the document’s current wording.

Part one in the series provides guidelines for evaluating any proposed state constitutional amendment.
 
A deep dive into each proposed amendment, covering the amendment’s history, sponsors,

…
Continue Reading The Legislature’s Three Proposed Changes to the Wisconsin Constitution: An Overview

The Wisconsin Court of Appeals last week held that a $20,000 municipal forfeiture for parking commercial trucks in a residential driveway was unconstitutionally excessive.

District 2 Judge Mark Gundrum issued the one-judge decision, overturning the sanction imposed by Lakeside Municipal Court on a city of Fond du Lac citation.

Dennis Murray appealed from the judgment finding him guilty of violating an ordinance prohibiting parking a commercial walk-in truck in a residential area.

Murray had argued at trial

…
Continue Reading Wisconsin Appeals Court Overturns $20,000 Municipal Forfeiture for Parking Commercial Trucks in Residential Area

The Wisconsin Supreme Court opens its session with oral arguments next week, including a case concerning the constitutionality of Wisconsin’s reverse waiver statute.“Reverse waiver” is used to describe a case that begins in adult court but is later transferred to juvenile court. Under the pertinent statute, adult circuit courts exercise original jurisdiction over various homicide charges for any child alleged to have committed the crime “on or after the juvenile’s 10th birthday.” That jurisdiction can only be transferred to

…
Continue Reading Wisconsin Supreme Court Opens Term with Case of Child Charged in Adult Court

Aug. 17, 2026 – An unborn child has a right of informed consent by statute, and with it, a right to pursue legal action against a doctor, the Wisconsin Supreme Court held in Brekke v. Midwest Medical Insurance Co., 2026 WI 29.

“Charlie May Brekke was a patient under [Wis. Stat. section 448.30] before her birth. Dr. Batley had a duty to obtain informed consent from Samantha regarding herself and Charlie,” wrote Chief Justice Jill J. Karofsky…
Continue Reading Supreme Court: Statute Requires Informed Consent to Unborn Child

Aug. 17, 2026 – The dispute in Cincinnati Insurance Co. v. Ropicky, 2026 WI 25, will return to circuit court after the Wisconsin Supreme Court held that damage from rain, but not damage resulting from the construction defect, was recoverable as an “ensuing loss.”

Justice Brian K. Hagedorn, writing for the 4-3 majority, said it was adopting Arnold v. Cincinnati Insurance Co., 2004 WI App 195, because it is “more consistent with normal language: that to ensue means…
Continue Reading Supreme Court: Rain Damage, Not Construction Defect, Recoverable

Aug. 17, 2026 – Whether a statutory proceeding to restore competency to trial also could authorize involuntary medication for dangerousness resulted in the Wisconsin Supreme Court holding 6-1 in State v. N.K.B., 2026 WI 22, that the proceedings are separate. The tally overstates agreement. The case became a dispute between three interpretations of the relevant statutes. “We conclude that the best way to read [Wis. stat. section 51.61(1)(g)3.] in light of [Wis. Stat. section 971.14]’s separate,…
Continue Reading Supreme Court: Competency to Stand Trial and Dangerousness Separate

July 22, 2026 – The Wisconsin Supreme Court agreed with the Wisconsin attorney general in his dispute with the Wisconsin Legislature to cont​rol settlement funds that the Wisconsin ​Department of Justice (DOJ) receives, in Wisconsin State Legislature v. Kaul, 2026 WI 28 (July 10, 2026).

“We conclude that the attorney general complies with [Wis. Stat. section 165.10] when, in accordance with the straightforward language of the statute, he deposits settlement funds into the general fund,” wrote…
Continue Reading Supreme Court: Attorney General Controls Settlement Funds

July 22, 2026 – A 65-year-old man’s appeal of a circuit court order continuing his protective placement in a nursing facility generated dissent among Wisconsin Supreme Court justices on whether the majority properly applied the standard of review in Racine County v. R.P.L., 2026 WI 26 (July 7, 2026).

The court held 4-3 in a decision authored by Justice Susan M. Crawford that under the “mixed question of fact and law” standard of review, the evidence was…
Continue Reading Supreme Court Debates Protective Placement Evidentiary Standards

July 15, 2026 – The Wisconsin Supreme Court denied a records request for Notice of Voting Eligibility (NVE) forms because a 5-2 majority interpreted the guardianship statutes as excepting the forms from a public records request in
Wisconsin Voter Alliance (WVA) v. Secord, 2026 WI 27.

“The legislature said, with limited exceptions, ‘court records pertinent to the finding of incompetency are closed,’” wrote Justice Janet C. Protasiewicz for the majority. “Thus, the [WVA] does not have a right…
Continue Reading Supreme Court: Voter Eligibility Forms Confidential

​

July 7, 2026 – Tribal sovereign immunity defeated a claim to bind real estate covenants to the Menominee Indian Tribe and its representative, a 4-3 Wisconsin Supreme Court majority held in Legend Lake Property Owners Association, Inc. v. Keshena, 2026 WI 21.

“We conclude that nothing abrogates, waives, or otherwise precludes the Tribe’s sovereign immunity in this case,” wrote Justice Susan M. Crawford for the majority. “Accordingly, we affirm the circuit court’s judgment of dismissal.”

Chief Justice…
Continue Reading Wisconsin Supreme Court: Sovereign Immunity Stops Covenant Enforcement